washington/jefferson star
  abraham lincoln
government foundations government institutions political behavior public policy home  
 
       
government foundations
 
democracy and political theory
the constitution
federalism
state and local government
civil liberties
civil rights
ideologies
 
 
global resources
citizen's survival guide
in the news
thinking globally, acting locally
current events quiz
english/spanish glossary
site map
 
Internet Activities: Federalism
 
 
 

Just the Facts, Please

1. Access the Citizen’s Guide to the Federal Budget (2001) (http://w3.access.gpo.gov/usbudget/fy2001/guidetoc.html)and answer the following questions:

  1. What is the total amount of receipts for fiscal year 2001? List the categories of taxes (by percentage, from large to small) that make up this budget.
  2. What is the total amount of outlays (expenditures) and the debt reduction? List by name the categories and amounts spent in this budget.

2. In our federal system, the relationship between the states and the national government is a dynamic, evolving story—one that has important effects on our daily lives. For an informative look at the history of federalism in the United States, go to http://www.min.net/~kala/fed/history.htm

Once at the site, do the following:

  • Scroll down to the box labeled "1900s" and describe the "stream of commerce" doctrine.
  • Click on the link to "child labor laws." What do the photos on this Web site add to the discussion? Do they help you understand the issue of child labor and its relationship to federalism?

Return to the main page and scroll down to the "New Federalism" section. What are three examples of how the new federalism has been implemented since the 1970s?

3. Goal: To study the history of federalism around the world.

URL: http://www.eurplace.org/federal/woodard.html

The federal system is one way of organizing a government. Although the United States has a 200 year history of a successful federal governmental system, other countries throughout the world also have federal governments of one form or another.

Go to the URL above and you will find a website devoted to studying federalism around the world. Read the Sections titled The History of the Federal Idea in Brief, the Origins of the Term Federal, Key Characteristics of a Federal Union, and Early Origins of the Federal Idea: the Historic Problem. Use what you have learned to answer the following questions:

  • List the first two federal unions of the modern era. These governments were _________ (loose or tight) unions with _________ (weak or strong) central authorities.
  • Who was Altiero Spinelli? What did he campaign for?
  • Describe how the 17th century puritan idea of a "federal theology" evolved to include agreements between states.
  • List and describe the six key characteristics of a federal union. Explain how the United States government meets these requirements.
  • Name the four purposes for which the Waldstatte was formed in 1291.

4. The Federalist Idea 200 Years Later

PBS Online and the WNET Public Television Station aired a series of programs relating the federalist idea to the current political climate. Go to the URL above and you will find the website that was associated with the program. Scroll down the left-hand column to the area called "Stories of Federalism." Select the link to "Federalism and the Supreme Court." Read the article and answer the following questions:

  • Briefly summarize the Supreme Court’s holding in U.S. v. Lopez.
  • Describe the South Dakota v. Dole decision. Didn’t the decision effectively mandate a federal drinking age of 21 years?
  • Go back to the main web page by selecting the back button on your browser or re-entering the URL listed at the beginning of this activity. Scroll down the left-hand column to the section marked The Federalist Papers. Select the link to the "New Federalist Papers." Read the article and answer the following questions:
  • List three areas that the author of the article maintains might strike the framers of the constitution as greatly changed from the original federalist ideas.
  • List two historical events that the author believes have greatly contributed to these changes.
  • Do you agree with the author of the article that we cannot ultimately "rely for our answers on Hamilton, Madison, Jay, or any of the framers of our government?" Why or why not?
 
   
return to top
 
       
       
    Compare & Contrast

1. Using the FindLaw Supreme Court (http://www.findlaw.com/casecode/supreme.html)Web site, find the following two cases, then compare and contrast the arguments made in the cases regarding the use of student activity fees. Compare and contrast the legal decisions made by the justices in each case. Cite the precedents used in the development of the majority, concurrent, and minority opinions.

Board of Regents of University of Wisconsin System v. Southworth (2000)
Rosenberger v. University of Virginia (1995)
 
       
   
return to top
 
       
       
   

Exploration

1. Access the Project Vote Smart (http://vote-smart.org/index.phtml) home page, then go to Principles for State-Federal Relations (http://www.nga.org/nga/legislativeUpdate/1,1169,C_ISSUE_BRIEF%5ED_3164,00.html). Discuss the different approaches to federalism presented there. Which ones are feasible and not feasible? Why and why not?

2. Access the Close Up Foundation (http://www.closeup.org/federal.htm)home page, then read "The New Federalism" article.

  1. What is your opinion about whether state governments will do a better job controlling welfare? Why or why not?
  2. What is your opinion about whether the federal government should influence how your town’s schools are run? Do you believe that local school boards should have control over what is taught and how education budgets are used? Defend your position with evidence and documentation.
  3. Are federal regulations necessary to protect the environment? Would state governments and grassroots organizations be able to enforce environmental guidelines on their own? Defend your position with evidence and documentation.

3. The New Federalism

Go to the Close Up Foundation Special Topic Page and notice the outline on "The New Federalism." Hit the respective links of the outline, read the material, and answer the following questions:

  • What is the meaning of "devolution"?
  • How has the New Deal, the Great Society, and the Reagan Revolution influenced federalism?
  • Why did President Clinton declare that "the era of big government is over" in 1996?
  • What was the significance of the new welfare reform law passed in 1996?
  • What arguments, pro and con, are related to this law?
  • In the area of education, review the arguments for and against federal involvement.
  • How have various levels of government been involved with the environmental problem?
  • After reading the outline material, do you believe that "devolution" will increase over time?
 
   
return to top