Politics and the Federal Court
Is the judicial branch affected by politics? There are two ways of examining this question. First, to what extent does politics affect the selection of federal judges and justices? Second, to what extent does the political ideology of judges affect their decisions?
Here are some articles to get you started. Find them through Keyword searches. Go to InfoTrac.
For more articles on this subject, enter:
"United States Supreme Court" in the Subject Guide, and then go to subdivision "officials and employees."
"United States Supreme Court" in the Subject Guide, and then go to subdivision "evaluation."
"United States Supreme Court" in the Subject Guide, and then go to subdivision "history."
"Clarence Thomas" in the Subject Guide.
"Robert Bork" in the Subject Guide.
"United States Supreme Court" in the Subject Guide, and then go to subdivision "political activity."
The Supremes' sophistry. John Leo. U.S. News & World Report July 14, 2003 v135 i1 p7 (741 words)
A Conservative View of the Court: Getting beyond 'activism' and 'restraint'. MICHAEL S. GREVE. National Review June 16, 2003 v55 i11 pNA (2076 words)
Rethinking the Death Penalty : POLITICIANS AND COURTS ARE TAKING THEIR CUES FROM GROWING PUBLIC OPPOSITION. Bruce Shapiro. The Nation July 22, 2002 v275 i4 p14 Mag.Coll.: 111J0127.
Courts v. Citizens: our increasingly right-wing judiciary has taken aim at the basic underpinnings of democracy. (Court Packing). Jamin B. Raskin. The American Prospect March 2003 v14 i3 pA24(2)
The bench tilts. (Devil In The Details). (Brief Article) The American Prospect Jan 13, 2003 v13 i24 p7(1)
Back to Bork? A new strategy of demanding nominees' views on judicial issues ensures that the next Supreme Court nomination battle will be ugly. (Politics). Byron York. The Atlantic Monthly March 2003 v291 i2 p30(3)
Catholics move to the center of the bench. (speculation on appointment of Catholic Supreme Court judges)(Column) Tim Unsworth. National Catholic Reporter Jan 24, 2003 v39 i12 p17(1)
Wolf in sheep's clothing? Appeals court nominee Michael McConnell is a nice guy, but critics say he has an extremist agenda on civil liberties. Rob Boston. Church & State Oct 2002 v55 i9 p12(3)
Infallible justice. (Antonin Scalia)(Brief Article) Patricia J. Williams. The Nation Oct 7, 2002 v275 i11 p9 Mag.Coll.: 111L0130.
Reconsidering "Bush v. Gore". (George W. Bush)(Al Gore) Gary Rosen. Commentary Nov 2001 v112 i4 p35(7)
The Kabuki mask of Bush v. Gore. (Case Note). (freedom of association) Nick Levin. Yale Law Journal Oct 2001 v111 i1 p223(8)
The 'Accidental President': Exclusive excerpt: The vote in Bush v. Gore was, like all decisions at the High Court, arrived at in secret conference. But this one determined who would be president. We didn't know just how close it was--until now. NEWSWEEK's DAVID A. KAPLAN goes behind the scenes. (National Affairs)(Cover Story)(Excerpt) David A. Kaplan. Newsweek Sept 17, 2001 p28
How History Will View the Court: Final ruling: The legal academy may still be blasting Bush v. Gore, but fears that the court would forfeit the public trust were overblown. (National Affairs)(the highly controversial Supreme Court decision) Newsweek Sept 17, 2001 p35
Bush v. Gore - A Case in Conservative Judicial Activism? Gerard V. Bradley. World and I June 2001 v16 i6 p292
THE TRIUMPH OF EXPEDIENCE. (Panel Discussion) PAMELA KARLAN, RICHARD POSNER. Harper's Magazine May 2001 v302 i1812 p31
The Supreme Court Shot Itself in the Foot While Shooting Down Al Gore. Mike Godwin. Reason March 2001 v32 i10 p50
To hear justices tell it, Bush v. Gore caused the court no disharmony. (U.S. Supreme Court and 2000 presidential election case) Tony Mauro. New Jersey Law Journal Feb 12, 2001 v163 i7 p6
Impeach the Supremes. (the Supreme Court judges who granted George W. Bush, election)(Brief Article) David Sarasohn. The Nation August 20, 2001 v273 i6 p4 Mag.Coll.: 108G0769.
The Betrayal. (Brief Article) PAUL STARR. The American Prospect Jan 1, 2001 v12 i1 p4
The Purloined Presidency. (2000 presidential election) HAROLD MEYERSON. The American Prospect Jan 1, 2001 v12 i1 p12
Bush v. Gore May Be Just The Beginning: The next big question will be whether W can tilt the high court to the right. (THE SUPREMES)(Nation)(Brief Article) Stuart Taylor Jr.. Newsweek Dec 25, 2000 p50
Can the Court Recover? Its controversial decision ended the election tangle but brought the high court as low as it has been in years. (Person Of The Year 2000) Time Dec 25, 2000 v156 i26 p76+
And now, sound and fury. (analysis of U.S. Supreme Court's judgement in Bush v. Gore) Marianne Lavelle, Chitra Ragavan. U.S. News & World Report Dec 25, 2000 v129 i25 p36
The Truth Behind the Pillars: The final act: They cultivate an Olympian air, but the justices are quite human--and can be quite political. (Nation) Newsweek Dec 25, 2000 p46 Mag.Coll.: 106F1103. Bus.Coll.: 131N1620.
The Winner in Bush v. Gore? It's Chief Justice Rehnquist, who runs the most trusted institution in the U.S. (William H. Rehnquist)(Brief Article) Charles Krauthammer. Time Dec 18, 2000 v156 i25 p104
Friend of the Court - Alberto Gonzales's high-wire act. Ryan Lizza. The New Republic May 27, 2002 p16
JUSTICE GONZALES? (Alberto R. Gonzales as possible US Supreme Court member)(Brief Article) Business Week May 20, 2002 i3783 p55
Religious Right Groups Demand Litmus Test For Supreme Court. (Brief Article) Church & State Oct 2001 v54 i9 p17
The education of Clarence Thomas. Tony Mauro. American Lawyer August 2001 v23 i8 p76
Here Come the Judges. (Supreme Court nominees )(Brief Article) The Nation April 16, 2001 v272 i15 p3 Mag.Coll.: 107E0232.
True God of the next justice. (Articles). (relevance of the Religious Test Clause to nomination and confirmation of Supreme Court justices) J. Gregory Sidak. Constitutional Commentary Spring 2001 v18 i1 p9(42)
Choosing better judges. (Supreme Court membership) Alan Gura. The American Enterprise March 2001 v12 i2 p25
A TICKING TIME BOMB IN THE SENATE. (possible obstacles that may occur over a Supreme Court judge nominee) KIRK VICTOR. National Journal Feb 17, 2001 v33 i7 p490
The Elections and the Supreme Court. (outcome of election to have impact on Supreme Court appointments) David C. Slade. World and I Nov 2000 v15 i11 p54
Putting a Radical Right Team on the Bench. (Supreme Court)(Brief Article) RALPH G. NEAS. The Nation Oct 9, 2000 v271 i10 p14 Mag.Coll.: 104G0187.
Scaremongering and the Court. (election outcome and Supreme Court appointments)(Brief Article) ALEXANDER COCKBURN. The Nation July 24, 2000 v271 i4 p8 Mag.Coll.: 103L0101.
THE BUSH COURT. RANDALL KENNEDY. The American Prospect Nov 23, 1999 v11 i1 p54
Justice without justices. (The Sound of Legal Thunder: The Chaotic Consequences of Crushing Constitutional Butterflies) John O. McGinnis. Constitutional Commentary Winter 1999 v16 i3 p541-547
The judicial confirmation process: a considered opinion. Robert A. Katzman. Brookings Review Wntr 1992 v10 n1 p5(1)
Never, ever come out swinging. (Clarence Thomas confirmation hearings) (Column) Florence King. National Review Dec 2, 1991 v43 n22 p64(1) Mag.Coll.: 62E0371.
Hill versus Thomas. (Anita Hill's charges of sexual harassment against Clarence Thomas) (Column) Jill Nelson. Essence Dec 1991 v22 n8 p134(1) Mag.Coll.: 62F1517.
The lost weekend. Lewis Cole. The Nation Nov 25, 1991 v253 n18 p679(2) Mag.Coll.: 62E0028.
Caricatures in search of an author. (On Theater - Clarence Thomas-Anita Hill hearings) (column) Robert Brustein. The New Republic Nov 18, 1991 v205 n21 p34(2) Mag.Coll.: 62C0183.
Presumed innocent? (Anita Hill) (editorial) Richard Pollak. The Nation Nov 11, 1991 v253 n16 p573(2) Mag.Coll.: 62C0034.
Rough justice: the plot that failed. (Clarence Thomas victim of smear campaign) Abigail Thernstrom. The New Republic Nov 11, 1991 v205 n20 p14(2) Mag.Coll.: 62C0115.
Minority report. (Clarence Thomas and African American conservatives) (Column) Christopher Hitchens. The Nation Nov 4, 1991 v253 n15 p542(1) Mag.Coll.: 62A0039.
What a whopper. (Washington Diarist - Clarence Thomas places the 'race card') (column) Hendrik Hertzberg. The New Republic Nov 4, 1991 v205 n19 p42(1) Mag.Coll.: 62A0143.
Here we go again. (hypocrisy of Supreme Court appointee confirmation rhetoric) (column) Michael Kinsley. The New Republic August 13, 1990 v203 n7 p6(2) Mag.Coll.: 56B0179.
Washington notebook. (on the Bork front; on the battle fronts; on the way to the summit) Daniel Schorr. The New Leader Oct 19, 1987 v70 n15 p5(2) Mag.Coll.: 41L4846.
The Bork screw. Andrew Sullivan. The New Republic Oct 19, 1987 v194 p14(2) Mag.Coll.: 41G0667.
To the bitter end; Robert Bork's decision to fight intensifies an already poisonous battle. (for confirmation as Supreme Court justice) Gloria Borger. U.S. News & World Report Oct 19, 1987 v103 p18(3) Mag.Coll.: 41H0293.
Democratic majority. (Democrats are majority party, exhibited by fight against Supreme Court Justice nominee Robert Bork) (editorial) The Nation Oct 17, 1987 v245 p397(1) Mag.Coll.: 41J1714.
Developing confirmation guidelines. (confirmation of Supreme Court nominees) Robert A. Katzmann. Brookings Review Fall 1993 v11 n4 p47(1)
The book of Ruth: Judge Ginsburg's feminist challenge. (Ruth Bader Ginsburg) (Cover Story) Jeffrey Rosen. The New Republic August 2, 1993 v209 n5 p19(5) Mag.Coll.: 69M0036.
Moderate threat. (TRB - Judge Ruth Bader Ginsburg) (Column) Mickey Kaus. The New Republic July 12, 1993 v209 n2 p6(1) Mag.Coll.: 69H0301.
Rethinking the Death Penalty : POLITICIANS AND COURTS ARE TAKING THEIR CUES FROM GROWING PUBLIC OPPOSITION. Bruce Shapiro. The Nation July 22, 2002 v275 i4 p14
Why the Supreme Court should not have decided the presidential election of 2000. Jesse H. Choper. Constitutional Commentary Summer 2001 v18 i2 p335(23)
The power of Congress over the rules of precedent. John Harrison. Duke Law Journal Nov 2000 v50 i2 p503
Taking its toll: partisan judging and judicial review. Jeff Broadwater. Journal of Appellate Practice and Process Spring 2002 v4 i1 p41(37)
Presidential Challenges to Judicial Supremacy and the Politics of Constitutional Meaning(*). Keith E. Whittington. Polity Spring 2001 v33 i3 p365
Split down the Right. (Supreme Court is politically right-winged)(Editorial)(Brief Article) The Nation July 20, 1998 v267 n3 p3(2) Mag.Coll.: 95E0638.
The Courts: Usurpation and Abdication. (Supreme Court and The Constitution)(Brief Article) National Review July 15, 2002 v54 i13 pNA
Bush Wants To Place Anti-Separationist Law Professor On Federal Court. (George W. Bush)(Brief Article) Church & State June 2001 v54 i6 p15 |
